Effect of vitamin A and vitamin C supplementation on oxidative stress in HIV and HIV-TB co-infection at Lagos University Teaching Hospital (LUTH) Nigeria.

Background: HIV and TB infections are both associated with elevated oxidative stress parameters. Anti-oxidant supplementation may offer beneficial effects in positively modulating oxidative stress parameters in HIV and HIV-TB infected patients. We investigated the effects of vitamin A and C supplementation on oxidative stress in HIV infected and HIV-TB co-infected subjects. Methods: 40 HIV/TB co-infected and 50 HIV mono-infected patients were divided into 2 equal groups. Participants provided demographic information and blood was collected to determine oxidative stress parameters before and after vitamin A (5000 IU) and C (2600 mg) supplementation for 1 month. Results: There was a significantly (p < 0.05) higher level of Malondialdehyde (MDA) at baseline for HIV infected subjects com pared with HIV-TB co-infected subjects. There was a significantly (p < 0.05) lower level of MDA and higher level of Catalase (CAT) in subjects administered supplementation compared to subjects without supplementation for the HIV infected group. There was a significantly lower level of Reduced Glutathione (GSH), Superoxide Dismutase (SOD) and higher level of MDA after one month of supplementation compared with baseline levels for HIV/TB co infected subjects. A similar result was also obtained for the HIV mono-infected groups which had a significantly lower level of SOD, MDA and CAT compared to the baseline. There was a significantly lower level of GSH and SOD, and higher level of MDA after supplementation compared with the baseline for HIV/TB co-infected subjects. Comparing the indices at baseline and post no-supplementation in HIV/TB co-infection showed no significant differences in the oxidative stress parameters Conclusion: HIV/TB co-infection and HIV mono-infection seems to diminish the capacity of the anti-oxidant system to con-trol oxidative stress, however exogenous anti-oxidant supplementation appears not to have beneficial roles in positively modu lating the associated oxidative stress.


Introduction
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome is a fatal illness caused by a retrovirus known as the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) that breaks down the body's immune system, infects CD4 + cells initially, progressively and ultimately leads to a chronic depletion of the immune system. 1,2 This syndrome is often associated with rare opportunistic infections which includes Mycobacterium tuberculosis, pneumonia and others. 3 Among the opportunistic pathogens associated with AIDS, Mycobacterium tubercu-losis possesses a large number of virulence factors and has a higher potential for person-to-person transmission. 4 Persons infected with HIV are particularly susceptible to tuberculosis, both from the reactivation of latent infection and from new infection with rapid progression to active disease. 5,6 In 2008, more than one-third of HIV-infected individuals were also infected with tuberculosis (TB). 7 Studies from 2007 show that of the 9.3 million new TB cases, 1.4 million were also living with HIV and 500,000 HIV positive TB patients died that same year. In many parts of the world TB is a leading cause of death in individuals infected with HIV. 7,8 It is believed that oxidative stress played a major role in the progression of HIV infection. 8,9,10 Oxidative stress is also associated with the pathophysiology of other disease like diabetes, and Alzheimer's disease. 11,12 Substantial amount of evidence revealed roles of Oxidative Stress (OS) as a contributory factor in many infections and drug related toxicities. 13 Experiments in animals have established the involvement of oxidative stress in drug induced toxic reaction. 14 A dysfunction of anti-oxidant system have also been observed in patients on anti-retroviral therapy, suggesting the roles of oxidative stress in antiretroviral toxicities, this is because Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy (HAART) seems to elevate reactive oxidative species in circulation, by producing more oxidized species due to the reactions between ROS and cellular molecular components. 15,16 HIV alone or and in combination with anti-retroviral therapies contributes to the development of oxidative stress in humans.
Oxidative stress also has been shown to be associated with TB infection through activation of phagocytes by mycobacteria which may further contribute to immunosuppression. 17,18 High level of oxidative stress has been reported in patients with tuberculosis as a result of tissue inflammation, poor nutrition and poor immunity and this stress becomes more severe in those with HIV-TB co-infection. Furthermore, a report has shown high levels of oxidative stress in HIV-TB co-infected patients. 19 Patients infected with HIV are in oxidative imbalance early in the disease; serum and tissue anti-oxidants levels are low and peroxidation products elevated. 20 High plasma levels of malondialdehyde (MDA), reduced plasma glutathione (GSH), and decreased superoxide dismutase (SOD) activities are normally found. HIV and TB infec-tion also result in considerably reduced vitamin C concentrations. 21 Anti-oxidant supplementation may help protect against oxidative stress associated with the infection and drug therapy. This study was therefore conducted to identify the modulatory roles of vitamin A and C supplementation on oxidative stress associated with HIV mono-infection and HIV-TB co-infection

Study site
The study was conducted at the AIDS Prevention Initiative of Nigeria (APIN) Clinic, Lagos University Teaching Hospital, Lagos, Nigeria; which is one of the treatment centers and a research center for the HIV relief program in Nigeria. The clinic runs from 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. (Monday to Friday) and has over 10,000 registered patients with an average of 200 patients attended to per day.

Subjects
A total of 90 consenting patients consisting of male and female adults with HIV infection (17 males, 33 females) and HIV-TB co-infection (10 males, 30 females) attending the AIDS Prevention Initiative of Nigeria (APIN) Clinic of the Lagos University Teaching Hospital (LUTH). This was a prospective randomized study to determine the effect of vitamin A 5000 IU and vitamin C 2600 mg on oxidative stress markers in HIV infected and HIV-TB co-infected patients.

Ethical approval and patients' consent
Ethical approval was obtained from the Research and Ethics Committee of Lagos University Teaching Hospital, (LUTH), Lagos, Nigeria.

Inclusion criteria
Subjects with HIV infection and HIV-TB co-infection ≥ 18 years of age who gave informed consent were used.

Exclusion criteria Patients with:
-Co-morbidities, such as renal, endocrine, hepatic diseases were excluded from the study so that they would not act as confounders to the study.
-Pregnant or lactating women were also excluded from the study. -CD4 count > 350 cells/micro-liter were also excluded from the study.
Sample population and study procedure Fifty (50) HIV infected and forty (40) HIV-TB co-infected subjects who met the inclusion criteria were recruited from 15 th May 2013 to 30 th January 2014. Information collected after obtaining consent includes bio-data, CD4 + count, viral load, hematological parameters and clinical chemistry parameters. HIV treatment naive subjects (50 subjects) were recruited as they presented to the clinic and 5mls of blood samples in heparinized vacutainer was collected for baseline oxidative stress parameters. Blood samples were collected at subjects' first clinic visit for estimation of full blood count, chemistry, CD4 + count and viral load 2 weeks prior to when samples for estimation of baseline oxidative stress parameters were collected. The 50 HIV infected subjects were systematically randomized into 2 groups as follows: I. 25 HIV infected subjects on supplementation (group A) II. 25 HIV infected subjects without supplementation (group B) 5mls of blood was collected from both groups; pre-supplementation and at 1month post-supplementation with vitamin A and vitamin C. The 40 HIV-TB co-infected subjects were systematically randomized into: I. 20 HIV-TB co-infected subjects on supplementation (group C) II. 20 HIV-TB infected subjects without supplementation (group D) 5mls of blood was collected from both groups; pre-supplementation and at 1month post-supplementation with vitamin A and vitamin C.

Modalities of providing supplementation
Group A and C were given supplements (Vitamin A 5000 IU and Vitamin C 2600 mg) contained in EMVITE multivitamin tablets. EMVITE multi-vitamin tablets produced by EMZOR Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd, with batch number 3 19698 and 04, 2013 as date of manufacture and 04, 2016 as expiry date were used. Each tablet con-tained vitamin A acetate 2500 IU, vitamin B1 600 mcg, vitamin D 250 IU, vitamin C 13000 mcg. It was ensured that subjects adhered to the required number of tablets to be taken daily. These doses can be tolerated in humans according to Pappolla et al, Schipper et al and Ayinde et al , hence were chosen for the study. 22,23,24 Sample and statistical analysis Plasma samples were separated from whole blood by centrifuging in a Whisperfuge centrifuge Model 684 (GEA Westfalia, Northvale, NJ, USA) at 2500 rpm for 10 minutes and was stored in Nuaire -80 o C ultralow temperature freezer, model number NU-9668E, serial number 08040061, until ready for analysis. CD4 + count, clinical chemistry and hematological parameters were determined using Automated Cy-flow counter; Hitachi 90 and Mindray BC 3200 respectively. Viral load was determined using Automated Ampliprep Cobas Taqman 48 analyzer.

Antioxidant enzymes assay
Measurements of anti-oxidant enzyme activity and lipid peroxidation were performed according to standard procedures. Catalase, superoxide dismutase (SOD), 25 malondialdehyde (MDA), 26 reduced glutathione (GSH) and were determined using the methods of Sedlak and Lindsay. 27

Result Bio-demographics Age range of the recruited HIV subjects
The results showed that the recruited HIV infected patients were in the age range 23 years to 58 years. Most were in the productive age group.

Sex distribution of recruited HIV subjects
The sex distribution of the subjects showed that the female: male ratio was in proportion of 2:1. A total of 17 male and 33 female HIV infected subjects who gave informed consent were recruited. (Fig. 1)

Age range of the recruited HIV-TB co-infected study subjects
The results showed that the recruited HIV-TB infected patients were in the age range 28 years to 58 years. Most were in their productive age group.

Sex distribution of the recruited HIV-TB co-infected study subjects
The sex distribution of the subjects showed that the female: male ratio was in proportion of 3:1. A total of 10 males and 30 females HIV-TB co-infected subjects who gave informed consent were recruited. (Fig. 2)

Baseline CD + count and viral load in HIV infected subjects
The mean baseline CD4 + count and viral load were 164.61 cells/μL and 540,284.44 copies/mL. The low CD4 + count and viral load showed both immune-depression and immuno-suppression.

Baseline clinical chemistry parameters in HIV-infected subjects
The mean baseline clinical chemistry parameters in the recruited HIV infected subjects showed that levels of urea and creatinine were 12.27 mol/L and 48.98 µmol/L respectively. These suggest that there was renal impairment. The mean values of hepatic enzymatic biomarkers; AST, ALT, ALP was also increased suggesting evidence of liver injury.

Oxidative stress parameters in HIV infected subjects one month post-supplementation
There was significant (p < 0.05) differences in CAT and MDA levels in HIV subjects one month post-supplementation. (Table 1)

Discussion
Oxidative stress is thought to play an important role in the progression of HIV infection. There is clear evidence that oxidative stress contributes to several aspects of HIV disease, including viral replication, inflammatory response and decreased immune cell proliferation. 28 There is a profound interplay of oxidative stress in tuberculosis. In pulmonary tuberculosis, there is increase in several circulating markers of free radical activity, indicating ongoing oxidative stress and decrease in anti-oxidant activity which may contribute to development of lung function abnormalities. 29 This study was conducted to investigate the modulatory effects of exogenous anti-oxidant supplementation on disease progression in HIV mono -infected and HIV-TB co-infected subjects.
Ninety subjects were recruited for this study; fifty HIV infected, and forty HIV/TB co-infected. Sex distribution of the recruited subjects showed that the ratio of male to female for the HIV mono-infected subjects was 2:1 while HIV/TB co-infected subjects had a ratio of 3:1. Therefore recruited subjects had similar sex distribution with a higher proportion of females in both groups.
The hematological parameters at baseline in the HIV infected group showed lower hemoglobin and red blood cell count compared with the general reference value hence suggesting anemia. A major feature in HIV patients is the presence of low level of hemoglobin and red blood cell. 30,31 Apart from HIV induced anemia, zidovudine is also associated with anemia especially in women. 31 The level of clinical chemistry parameters in HIV infected subjects at baseline shows elevated mean total protein, AST and ALT levels and a lower level of creatinine compared to the normal reference range. This shows a possibility of hepatotoxicity that is characterized by an elevation of hepatic enzymatic biomarkers. One of the adverse effects of anti-retroviral therapy is hepatotoxicity and is frequently reported in patients taking nevirapine containing highly active antiretroviral therapy. Case reports, clinical trials and other studies have linked nevirapine with hepatotoxicity in HIV patients taking nevirapine containing ART. 32 In this study, there was a significantly higher level of CAT in HIV mono-infected subjects who had no supplementation when compared with subjects administered vitamin A and vitamin C. Also, the oxidative stress indices were significantly lower in the post-supplementation group compared to baseline. HIV infected subjects have been shown to have decreased anti-oxidant concentrations, disruption in glutathione metabolism and enhanced spontaneous generation of reactive oxygen species. 33 Fri- is-Moller et al. 20 have shown that HIV-infected patients are in oxidative imbalance early in the disease; serum and tissue anti-oxidants levels are low and lipid peroxidation products elevated. These supplements were unable to correct this oxidative state or induce an increase/stimulation of the anti-oxidant system. The first stage of metabolism of vitamin C converts it into a free radical 34 which could exacerbate oxidative stress in conditions characterized by excessive oxidation. This is further corroborated by the significantly lower levels of MDA in subjects who had no supplementation when compared with the subjects who had supplementation. According to Mehta and Fawzi, 35 advanced HIV disease may suppress release of vitamin A from the liver and would result in low levels of vitamin A in the plasma despite the body having enough vitamin A liver stores. These authors 35 also reported that the HIV genome has a retinoic acid receptor element hence vitamin A may increase HIV replication via interacting with this receptor. Vitamin A is also known to increase lymphoid cell differentiation, which leads to an increase in CCR5 receptors which are essential for attachment of HIV to the lymphocytes and therefore, an increase in their number is likely to increase HIV replication. This may be a probable mechanism for the non-efficacious effect of this vitamin seen in this study.
In HIV-TB co infected subjects in this study, there were significantly higher levels of GSH and SOD in subjects who had no supplementation compared with the Vitamin A and C administered subjects. Comparing post-supplementation levels of oxidative stress indices with baseline showed significantly lower levels of SOD and CAT with a corresponding significantly higher level of MDA at post-supplementation. Loss of appetite, poor intestinal absorption, increased urinary loss of vitamin A or acute phase reaction in tuberculosis 36 may contribute to these findings and portends that these supplements were unable to confer protective roles as anti-oxidants against oxidative stress at the experimental doses used and may provide no benefit also in HIV-TB coinfection.
A higher level of MDA in these subjects points to increased lipid peroxidation further indicating the inability of vitamin C and A to shield the patients from medication or infection induced oxidation and hence disease progression.

Conclusion
This study shows that there are no positive modulatory roles and benefits of vitamin C and A supplementation on oxidative stress indices in HIV mono-infected and HIV-TB co-infected patients.

Conflict of interest
There are no conflicts of interest with respect to the study.