Desegregating health statistics and health research in South Africa
Abstract
Objective. This article aims: (I) to re-examine the use and usefulness of categorisation based on 'race'. ethnicity and 'population group' membership in public heatth research; and (ii) to assess the consequences of using these categories for describing, analysing and redressing disparities in health within South Africa The utility of categorisation based on 'race', ethnicity and 'population group', Categorising populations and comparing patterns of disease between different groups of people can be a useful technique for identifying potential causes of disease. In this context, equality is a valid social concept that could be used to investigate the consequences of self-ascribed identity on health. Likewise,the population group'. as defined dUring apartheid in South Africa, represents a valid political concept that could be used for assessing the impact of social discrimination on heatth~ However, both these concepts are often seen, and used, as euphl?fTlisms for 'race'. even though there are no genetically distinct human subspecies that can be identified and categorised as discrete 'races'. Indeed,' ~ a biological concept has no validity in human biology. Nevertheless, categories based on 'race', ethnicity and 'population group' continue to be used in health research, and reinforce the perception that differences in disease between different 'racial', ethnic and 'population' groups are the result of heritable biological characteristics.In so doing, they undermine support for health interventions that would otherwise address the social and political origins of 'racial' and ethnic disparities in health. The utility of 'popUlation group' for redressing the consequences of apartheid. Despite these problems, 'population group' classification provides important , information for assessing the impact of~don disparities in health within South Africa Yet, the abolition of apartheid legislation is likely to ~sult in extensive \ socio-economic and geographical migration that will \ ~the sensitivity and specificity of 'population group' as an indicator for identifying inequalmes in health. For this reason, targeting corrective action at specific population groups in order to tackle disparities in health, runs the risk of ignoring alternative social causes of inequalities in health. and ignoring disadvantaged individuals from elsewhere in the population. The continued use of 'population group' classification might also perpetuate the root cause of disparities in health, by maintaining the process used to formalise discrimination.
Conclusion. If the purpose of health researchis to monitor inequalities in health and to help target resources aimed at reducing these inequalities, then it should seek, in its language, concepts and methods to undermine the root cause of disadvantage. Health research aimed at monitoring and redressing the consequences of social disadvantage on health should therefore focus on non~ biological determinants of social disparities in he~ As a general rule, health researchers should avoid using categories based on 'race', ethnicity and 'population group' when collecting and analysing health data; journal editors should not accept articles that use these categories without justification; and health authorities should not collect data routinely segregated by 'race', ethnicity or 'population group'.
Copyright remains in the Author’s name. The work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution - Noncommercial Works License. Authors are required to complete and sign an Author Agreement form that outlines Author and Publisher rights and terms of publication. The Agreement form should be uploaded along with other submissions files and any submission will be considered incomplete without it [forthcoming].
Material submitted for publication in the SAMJ is accepted provided it has not been published or submitted for publication elsewhere. Please inform the editorial team if the main findings of your paper have been presented at a conference and published in abstract form, to avoid copyright infringement. The SAMJ does not hold itself responsible for statements made by the authors.
Previously published images
If an image/figure has been previously published, permission to reproduce or alter it must be obtained by the authors from the original publisher and the figure legend must give full credit to the original source. This credit should be accompanied by a letter indicating that permission to reproduce the image has been granted to the author/s. This letter should be uploaded as a supplementary file during submission.