Effect of replacing grass hay with maize silage as a basal diet on milk yield and composition of dairy cows

  • Ewonetu Kebede
  • Feyisa Hundessa
Keywords: Grass hay, Milk composition, Milk yield, Maize silage


The objective of this study was to determine effect of replacing grass hay with maize silage on milk production and composition. The study was conducted at Haramaya University dairy research farm -using sixteen crossbred dairy cows (Zebu × Holstein-Friesian) which were assigned to two treatment groups. Each treatment group consisted of eight cows and arranged in a completely randomized experimental design. Cows in both treatment groups were provided similar supplemental concentrate ration formulated from various ingredients but fed on different basal diets which were silage and grass hay. The feeding trial was conducted for a total of 90 days. Milk yield of individual cows were recorded every day and analyzed every two weeks for its chemical composition. Data were analyzed by t-Test for means. The group of cows fed on grass hay relatively produced higher milk yield (17.1) than cows fed on silage (16.1 liters per day). The protein, total solid, solid not fat, and milk urea nitrogen composition were found significantly different between a group of cows fed grass hay and silage. Silage-fed cows gave higher percentage of fat and protein content throughout the experimental period. Milk urea-nitrogen concentration was intensive in cows fed on hay and it was higher than the acceptable range (12 to 18 mg/dl) for the two experimental diets. In conclusion, farmers could use both grass hay and maize silage as substitute to each other in dairy cow diets that could ensure higher quantity and quality milk production.


AOAC (2012). Official Methods of Analysis. 19th ed. Gaithersburg: AOAC International.

Beauchemin, K.A., Rode, L.M and Eliason, M.V. (1997). Chewing activities and milk production of dairy cows fed alfalfa as hay, silage, or dried cubes of hay or silage. Journal of Dairy Science 80: 324-333.

Carlsson, J and Pehrson, B. (1994). The influence of the dietary balance between energy and protein on milk urea concentration. Experimental trials assessed by two different protein evaluation systems. Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica 35: 193-205.

Cattani, M., Guzzo, N., Mantovani,R and Bailoni, L. (2017). Effects of total replacement of corn silage with sorghum silage on milk yield, composition, and quality. Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology 8: 15.

Colombini, S., Rapetti, L., Colombo, D., Galassi, G and Crovetto, G.M. (2010). Brown midrib forage sorghum silage for the dairy cow: nutritive value and comparison with corn silage in the diet. Italian Journal of Animal Science 9(3):273–77.

ÇÖsKalac, P. (2011). The effects of silage feeding on some sensory and health attributes of cow milk: A review. Food Chemistry 125(2): 307-317.

Coulon, J.B., Pradel, P and Verdier, I. (1997). Effect of forage conservation (hay or silage) on chemical composition of milk. Annales de zootechnie, INRA/EDP Sciences 46 (1): 21-26.

Ewonetu Kebede (2018). Effect of cattle breed on milk composition in the same management conditions. Ethiopian Journal of Agricultural Science 28(2): 53-63.

Fitzgerald, J.JandMurphy, J.J.(1999). A comparison of low starch maize silage and grass silage and the effect of concentrate supplementation of the forages or inclusion of maize grain with the maize silage on milk production by dairy cows. Livestock Production Science 57: 95–111.

Guggisberg, C (2011). Was Schweizer Konsumenten wünschen und wir von Österreich lernen können (German), Coop Schweiz, http://www.swissmilk.ch/de/produzenten/services-fuermilchproduzenten/bauernevents-fachmessen/suisse-tier/-dl-/fileadmin/filemount/dokumentsmp-suisse-tier-fachtagung-heu-milch-guggisberg-coop-konsumenten-wuensche-vonoesterreich-lernen-2011-11-19-de.pdf. Accessed 10-9-2018.

Kalač, P and Samková, E. (2011). The effects of feeding various forages on fatty acid composition of bovine milk fat: a review. Czech Journal of Animal Science 55(12):521–37.

Kolver, E.S., Roche, J.R., Mıller, D and Densley, R. (2001). Maize silage for dairy cows.Proceedings of the New Zealand Grassland Association 63: 195-201.

Macleod, G.K., Colucci, P.E., Moore, A.D., Grieve, D.G and Lewis, N. (1994). Theeffectsof feedingfrequencyof concentrates and feeding sequence of hay on eating behavior, ruminal environment and milk production in dairy cows. Canadian Journal of Animal Science 74: 103-113.

Martin, B., Priolo, A., Valvo, M.A., Micol, D and Coulon,J.B. (2005). Effects of grass feeding on milk, cheese and meat sensory properties. (Sustainable grazing, nutritional utilization and quality of sheep and goat products). Options Mediterraneennes 67: 213-223.

McCormick, M.E., Han, K.J., Moreira, V.R., Blouin, D.C and Forbes, S. (2011). Forage conservation efficiency and lactation response to bahiagrass conserved as barn-stored hay, outdoor-stored hay or baleage. Journal of Dairy Science 94: 2500-2507.

McDonald, P., Henderson, N and heron, S. (1991). The Biochemistry of silage. 2nd ed. Chalcombe Publications, Marlow, Great Britain, 340.

McGechan, M.B. (1989). A Review of Losses Arising during Conservation of Grass Forage: Part 1, field losses. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research 44: 1-21.

McGechan, M.B. (1990). A Review of Losses Arising during Conservation of Grass Forage: Part 2, storage losses. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research 45: 1-30.

Mech, A., Dhali, A., Prakash, B and Rajkhowa, C. (2008). Variation in milk yield and milk composition during the entire lactation period in Mithun cows (Bos frontalis), Livestock Research for Rural Development 20(5): 56-57.

NRC (2001). Nutrient requirements of dairy cattle. 7th rev. Ed. National Academy Press, Washington, D.C.

O’Mara, F.P., Fitzgerald, J.J., Murphy,J.J and Rath, M. (1998). The effect on milk production of replacing grass silage with maize silage in the diet of dairy cows.Livestock Production Science 55: 79–87.

Olesen, N.A., Eskedal, H.W., Østergaard, P.S and Rottensten, K. (1937). Forsøg med hø og ensilage (In Danish), Den Kgl. Veterinær- og Landbohøjskoles Landøkonomiske Forsøgslaboratorium, Copenhagen, Denmark, 149.

Pollott, G.E. (2004). Deconstructing milk yield and composition during lactation using biologically based lactation models. Journal of Dairy Science 87(8): 2375–2387.

Sousa, D.P., Campos, J.M.S., Valadares Filho, S.C., Lana, R.P., Sediyama, C.A.Z and Mendes Neto, J. (2009). Comportamento ingestivo, consumo e digestibilidade de nutrientes, produção e composição do leite de vaca alimentadas com silagem de milho ou cana-de-açúcar com caroço de algodão. Revista Brasileira de Zootecnia 38: 2053-2062.

Van Soest, PJ. (1994). Nutritional ecology of the ruminant. 2nd ed. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York, USA, pp. 477.

Verdier-Metz, I., Coulon, J.B., Pradel, P., Viallon, C and Berdague, J.L. (2005). Effect of forage conservation (hay or silage) and cow breed on the coagulation properties of milks and on the characteristics of ripened cheeses. Journal of Dairy Research 85(6): 469-480.

Viana, P.T., Pires, A.J.V., Oliveira, L.B., Carvalho, G.G.P., Ribeiro, L.S.O., Chagas, D.M.T., Nascimento Filho, C.S and Carvalho, A.O. (2012). Fracionamento de carboidratos e de proteína das silagens de diferentes forrageiras. Revista Brasileira de Zootecnia 41: 292-297.

Yoon, J.T., Lee, J.H., Kim, C.K., Chung, Y.C and Kim, C.H. (2004). Effects of milk production, season, parity and lactation period on variations of milk urea nitrogen concentration and milk components of Holstein dairy cows. Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences 17: 479-484.


Journal Identifiers

eISSN: 2312-6019
print ISSN: 1816-3378